Miles Head may not have been known to too many before he was shipped from Boston to Oakland this off-season as a part of the Andrew Bailey trade, but he's been known to prospect-followers for quite some time.
Drafted in the 26th round by the Red Sox in 2009, Head was bought out of a commitment to the University of Georgia with an over-slot $335,000 bonus. At the time, Baseball America said:
If only Lane and Miles Head could share tools. Head has a bad body but is the best prep hitter in the state this year, in terms of pure hitting ability, and is a key Georgia recruit. He could go in the fifth to eighth round to a team that believes he can catch or hold down third base defensively. His arm is fringe-average, and he could be a playable defender at the college level. Then scouts could see if he improves his conditioning and tones up his body. He repeats his short swing and has some present strength, and he could contribute immediately with the Bulldogs next spring.
The ability was there, but scouts didn't like the body and weren't sure if he could handle any position other than first base. Three years later, not much has changed.
Head played at short-season Lowell in 2010 and demonstrated great plate discipline, but little power. But while his .669 OPS was unimpressive, his 16 doubles and 36:30 strike out to walk ratio in 272 plate appearances signified strong potential for the future.
That potential reared its head in 2011, when Head broke out in his first taste of full-season baseball. Beginning the year in Low-A Greenville of the South Atlantic League, Head hit .338/.409/.612 in 66 games with 25 doubles and 15 home runs. The breakout was needed, as the Red Sox had already determined that Head's future was at first base, not third.
The dominance of the Sally League earned Head a mid-season promotion to the difficult-on-hitters Carolina League. Head certainly didn't dominate his new competition the same way, but he held his own, posting a .733 OPS in the remaining half-season.
The off-season brought a change for Head, as he was traded to Oakland (along with Ryan Sweeney and pitching prospect Rual Alcantara) for closer Andrew Bailey as a part of the Red Sox mismanaged off-season roster assembly.
Beginning back at High-A, Head is a prime example of the difference in hitting environments between the Carolina and California League, as well as the difference a year can make. Head took the California League by storm, hitting .382/.433/.715 with 23 doubles and 18 home runs in 67 games. The ridiculous hitting environments of the California League made it impossible to truly gauge Head, so the A's promoted him to Double-A for the remainder of the season.
Once again, a promotion brought Head back down to Earth, although he once again handled his new assignment admirably for a young player at a new level. Head hit .272/.338/.404 with Midland, but once again, his power production dropped off dramatically.
The A's also tried Head back out at third base at both levels in an attempt to maximize his value and allow his bat to play more. Reports on Head's defense at third base were far from glowing, with most implying that he could handle the position well enough to justify playing him there only if he hits like he did in the California League.
The future for Head is still largely the same as it was in 2009 when he was drafted, just not as far away.
The jury is still very much out on Head's future as a third baseman, but it doesn't look good for him playing there every day. With enough experience, he may be able to play there occasionally, at least early in his career, but it's not going to be a long-term destination for him.
Which means he needs to hit. Early in his career, Head demonstrated good plate discipline to go along with his power. That has deteriorated as he has moved up the minor league ladder, which is not a good sign for his development. If he is going to have value as a right-handed hitting first baseman, he'll need to continue to develop his power but also get on base. The good news, if it continues to hold true, is that Head has a reverse platoon split, meaning that as a right-handed hitter, he actually hits right-handed pitching much better than he does left-handers. That will keep him from being stuck on the short-end of a platoon if he gets a manager that actually looks at the numbers.
The other good news for Head is that he's still just 21. He'll probably repeat the Texas League next season, at least to start the season, and still has plenty of time to work out the kinks offensively. The A's will probably continue to work with him at third base, and should. He'll never be great down there, but even if he can become passable, his bat plays much better and it will give him the flexibility to avoid being pigeon-holed at first.
Head still has the natural hitting ability that can't be taught and that alone will continue to push him up the minor league ranks and should give him a nice major league career. The path of that career will be determined by his development at third base and his plate discipline.