The Washington Nationals pulled the trigger on a trade for left-handed pitcher Gio Gonzalez, sending prospects Derek Norris, Brad Peacock, A.J. Cole, and Tom Milone to the Oakland A's in return. Norris, Peacock and Cole were all listed in Baseball America's Top-10 Nationals prospects.
Norris likely has the highest ceiling of the four prospects, but the Nationals have significant organizational depth at catcher, and could afford to make a deal. Despite batting just .210 last season, he still demonstrated strong plate discipline and solid power. Matt Eddy of Baseball America has a complete scouting report on all four prospects, while Bernie Pleskoff of MLB.com says both teams fulfilled their goals.
Keith Law of ESPN.com has his own breakdown of the trade, and believes the A's got both quality and quantity in this deal. On the other hand, Marc Hulet of FanGraphs.com wonders where the rest of the return is for the A's.
I happen to side with Hulet on this one. While the A's got good depth, the Nationals didn't give up anything they can't live without, or replace in their next draft. They didn't have to part with Bryce Harper (not that they would have), and while Cole has a high ceiling, he's got quite a way to go to get to the majors. Peacock has turned himself into a nice prospect, but his ceiling isn't any higher than what Gonzalez is right now. Norris should be a nice player, but the Nationals are one of the few teams that had the depth to part with a power-hitting young catcher.
The Nationals unloaded some of their minor league depth, but did so in order to improve their major league pitching depth. While the trade is by no means lopsided, I don't think the Nationals will regret anything they've lost.

