Alen Hanson's bat has plenty of potential in it, enough that if he has to eventually move away from his current short stop position, he should still be able to be a productive major league hitter, but wouldn't it be nice if the Pirates could keep him at his natural position, where his bat would be an above-average asset?
That's what Pirates fans are hoping, but Tim Williams of PiratesProspects.com isn't so sure if Hanson will be able to stay there. Williams goes into good detail the problems that Hanson is having in the field (give the article a read for a great explanation into Hanson's struggles). I wanted to look at the developmental decisions his defensive issues may force the Pirates to make.
As Williams points out, it's not the tools or ability that are lacking for Hanson, but the consistency, with most of his errors and miscues coming on the more routine plays. This is a problem we see with a lot of young players. They have the ability to make great plays, but lack the focus and consistency to make all of the routine ones. And as a major league shortstop, you have to be able to make virtually all of the routine plays. Hanson is still quite young, so there's plenty of time for him to outgrow his lack of focus, but depending on how his bat develops, that window could shrink.
We saw this happen recently with Billy Hamilton. The Reds speedster played an erratic short stop for his first few years of the minors, and scouts were split on whether or not he'd ever be consistent enough to play the position in the major leagues. As his offensive game developed more rapidly, the point became moot, as the Reds realized that even if he could eventually be a good enough defensive short stop, the process of becoming so would take much longer than they wanted to wait for his bat. They moved him to center field after last season.
The same fate may await Hanson. Whether or not he can eventually develop into a good short stop may be rendered moot if his bat develops quickly. If he hits this season the way he did last year, the Pirates will want to get him to the majors soon, perhaps by the end of the 2014 season. He'll probably need more time than that do become a good enough short stop to play there in the majors.
If the Pirates see his bat developing quickly, he has the tools to shift to second or third base. A shift to third could coincide with current third baseman Pedro Alvarez shifting to first base, a move many see as inevitable. He also has the athletic ability to handle the outfield, but such a move would further diminish his overall value.
Hanson won't be 21 until after this season, so there's no need to rush either his bat or his glove. Having to move a potent hitter to another position because his bat is ready before his glove isn't the worst problem to have, but if the Pirates can be patient with Hanson, they could have the best of both worlds. But there is the chance that there is simply too much work here to be done.